A Guide to Choosing the Best Mustache Wax

There was a time not so many years ago when mustaches were definitely considered creepy on most men. Luckily though, we’ve again reached a point where a stache can again be considered stylish, possibly even sexy, especially in the month for Movember, as it is for a good cause. That being said, whether you’re going for a handlebar, rock star, porn stache, or any of the other best mustache styles, there’s a fine line between a stylish, well groomed mustache and something altogether more sloppy, unrefined and flat out unattractive.

Keeping your mustache looking good obviously involves keeping it well trimmed and keeping the rest of your facial hair with the right shaving supplies, but just as important is knowing the secrets to keeping all of those hairs perfectly in place on your lip. The key to having a seductively stylish mustache lies in mustache wax. Even if you’re not planning on entering a mustache competition with your immaculately styled stache, a small amount of mustache wax can still be your best friend. Of course, like everything else in life, not all waxes are created equally—meaning there are a few important things you need to understand in order to find the best mustache wax for your face and facial hair.

Best Mustache Waxes

Why Use Mustache Wax?

Before we get into how to find the best mustache wax, it’s first necessary to look into why you need it in the first place. In truth, probably not all mustaches really require waxing. However, even the thinnest, wispiest staches will still suffer stray or unruly hairs from time to time, which can quickly be put in their place with a good wax. On the same token, a wax will also help make that thin or wispy mustache look thicker and fuller.

Some people refer to mustache waxes as a training wax, and for good reason. If there is a specific style you’ve got your sights set on, such as a curling handlebar (or any other style that seems to defy gravity), you’ll absolutely need to invest in a wax in order to achieve that style. A good wax will stiffen up the hairs and help hold them in place, making it possible to achieve your dream stache style. Waxing your mustache will also help to keep the hairs away from your mouth, which is definitely a big turn off for most ladies.

However, the reason some people refer to them as a training wax is that it is actually possible to begin training your facial hair to hold that style. While some styles will always need the help of a stiff wax to hold them in place, achieving the style will nonetheless become easier over time as the hairs will eventually start to grow out and stay more or less in the style you want (even if you’ll still have to take the time to curl the ends of your stache every day). With a little help, you can easily train your stache to go out sideways instead of falling straight down towards your mouth.

Important Items to Consider On Your Search for the Best Mustache Wax

If you’ve never used a mustache wax before, you may be surprised to know that there are a ton of different options out there, and we’re not just talking about different brands here. Mustache waxes come in different colors, thicknesses and even strengths, so it’s important to know what you’re looking for before you just run out and buy the first wax you see. Of course, the sheer number of different waxes out there means you may need to do some serious experimenting before you find the best mustache wax for your facial hair and your stache style. That being said, here are some of the things you’ll need to consider.

  • Strength/Stiffness. Mustache waxes come in a variety of stiffnesses or strengths, ranging from mild hold to extreme. If you’re simply looking to keep those stray hairs in place, you can definitely just go with a softer wax. However, if you’re looking to totally style or shape your stache, you should probably consider choosing a stiffer wax that will set up firm and hold everything firmly in place. Just keep in mind that the stiffer or harder the wax is, the more difficult it will be to remove at the end of the day (in fact, some waxes may require a special wax remover to be fully washed off). On the other hand, if you live in a very hot climate, you may want to stay away from the softer waxes, as they tend to melt and lose their holding power when the temperature gets too high.
  • Scent. While you may not think that scent is a huge deal, remember that you’ll be wearing the wax directly underneath your nostrils. So it is important to choose something that you’re comfortable with smelling all day.
  • Color. Mustache waxes also come in a variety of different colors, meaning it is important to choose something that at least somewhat resembles the shade of your facial hair. On the other hand, you could also choose a neutral colored mustache wax, but be aware that some so-called neutral waxes are actually white and thus may accentuate or call attention to any gray hairs. On the other hand, a darker colored wax can actually help to hide gray hairs.

The Best Mustache Waxes on the Market Today

#1 Wild Willie’s Stache Wax

Wild Willie's Stache WaxWe’re huge fans of the Wild Willie’s line of grooming products from The Manskape Co., having previously featured both their beard balm and beard oil in earlier posts. As the #1 best-selling mustache wax on Amazon, Wild Willie’s Stache Wax obviously deserves a place on this list. The reason we like the brand so much is that they only ever use all-natural and organic ingredients, plus all of their products are handmade in the USA.

Wild Willie’s Stache Wax is a very stiff wax that is perfect for longer hair or when you need some serious hold. However, as a stiff wax, it can also be quite difficult to remove (which is why the company makes a wax remover). The smell is quite mild and pleasant, and all in all, this is definitely a great product. However, I have found that it is much stiffer than I could ever need, which is why I’d probably only recommend it for those who need some serious styling help.

#2 Woodsman Mustache Wax

Woodsman Mustache WaxOne of my personal favorites, Woodsman Mustache Wax from The Bearded Bastard is another very strong, stiff wax that makes achieving even the most daring stache styles a breeze. Like most of the others on our list, this product is made using only natural and organic ingredients. Out of all of our choices for the best mustache waxes, this one definitely has one of the manliest, most rugged scents. With a combination of cedarwood, sandalwood and pine essential oils, the scent definitely lives up to the Woodsman name. However, it is important to note that some men may experience skin irritation or allergies from these oils, which is why the manufacturer recommends doing a skin test before slathering it on your stache.

#3 Honest Amish Beard Wax

Honest Amish Beard WaxHonest Amish is another one of the major names when it comes to beard and mustache balms, oils and waxes. While they advertise this product as a beard wax, it works just as well at styling and holding a stache. Compared to the two previous products, this one isn’t nearly as stiff, making it better suited for those who just need to add a bit of hold or keep those rogue hairs in place. In truth, this is one of the best mustache waxes I’ve ever used as I prefer a softer wax that doesn’t leave my face and hair feeling overly stiff or greasy. It has a very mild, pleasing scent reminiscent of cinnamon, licorice and spices, which quickly fades away after it is applied. Hones Amish Beard Wax is also neutral colored, making it suitable for use on any beard or mustache around.

#4 Fisticuffs Mustache Wax

Fisticuffs Mustache WaxFisticuffs Mustache Wax is another traditional, old-school wax that provides an incredible amount of hold. As a stiff wax, you’ll need to work it in your hands for a bit longer before applying it, but as soon as it’s on you can simply forget about it and go on about your day knowing full well that every hair in your mustache is perfectly in place. This is another neutral colored wax, which is available in three different scents—original, lavender and bay rum. I personally prefer the original scent, which has a nice citrusy smell. However, the lavender is also incredibly nice and not nearly as feminine as you’d imagine.

Although I definitely like the level of hold this product provides, there is one thing that I definitely don’t like. While most of the other products on our list of the best mustache waxes contain only natural ingredients, this one unfortunately contains petroleum jelly. Now this might not be a problem for some people, but if you’re one of those who prefer to only use natural ingredients for your grooming needs, you should definitely consider one of the others on this list instead.

#5 Stache Bomb Stache Wax

Stache Bomb Stache WaxHandmade in made using locally sourced beeswax, Stache Bomb Stache Wax is definitely one of our favorite softer mustache waxes we’ve yet to come across. Unlike those stiff, hard to use products that are unnecessary for most men, this is one all-around great product that should satisfy even the most demanding connoisseurs. It features a very manly, pleasant scent that is reminiscent of citrus and pine, while providing just enough hold to keep those stray hairs in place throughout the day. So if you’re looking for a soft, nice-smelling wax, this really is the bomb.

#6 Firehouse Moustache Wax

Firehouse Moustache WaxAvailable in three different colors, Firehouse Moustache Wax is a favorite of many men out there, and for good reason, as this stuff will make your stache style able to stand up to almost anything. The Firehouse Light wax is designed for those men with blonde or gray facial hair, while the Firehouse Dark is better for men with reddish or brownish hair. Finally, the Firehouse Wacky Tacky Moustache Wax is perfect for any darker shade of hair. The Wacky Tacky is the company’s best selling and also their strongest, stiffest wax, but personally, I prefer the Dark as it is slightly softer and easier to use. Still, no matter what your hair color is, you can’t go wrong with Firehouse.

Honorable Mention: Clubman Mustache Wax

Clubman Mustache WaxI struggled mightily with whether or not to include Clubman Mustache Wax on this list, but I figured I had to simply due to its immense popularity. Don’t get me wrong, I am fan of Clubman products. They even made the list for best aftershaves, but before I get into my own personal opinions, first we’ll look into the good things about this product. For starters, this is a very soft, moldable wax, which is quite easy to use and provides a decent level of hold. Unlike the other products on our list, all of which come in a tin, Clubman Mustache Wax comes in a tube. This makes it easy to apply, but also makes it much more likely that you’ll end up squeezing out way more than you need. It is available in three different colors—white/neutral, chestnut and brown—so you should be able to easily match the color of your facial hair (although I’d recommend avoiding the white if you don’t want to accentuate those white or gray hairs in your stache). This product also comes with a special mustache comb that makes it easier to apply the product and style your mustache.

Additional Important Notes

Ok, so far so good, right? All of these things are definitely positive and make it easier to understand the popularity of this product. However, despite all of these good factors, there are definitely a few things about this one that I and many other men don’t like. First of all, despite being quite soft and moldable, many men have commented that it begins to feel more like a lue than a wax once it begins to dry out. In fact, I’d liken the feeling to using hairspray or gel on your mustache, as although it provides a decent hold, it makes the hairs feel quite stiff and brittle. In addition, this one has a quite unpleasant smell and taste until it dries. Although this only takes a few minutes, it can still be fairly off-putting until you get used to it. Still, if you’ve tried out all of the other waxes on our list and are looking for something a bit different, this one might be right up your alley—so don’t let my problems with it discourage you from at least giving it a try.

Hey! Don’t Leave Yet!

If you found this article helpful please be so kind as to share it on Facebook or other social media per the buttons below. We really would appreciate it as we have worked so hard on this post for you. I have a feeling some of your friends and family will find it helpful as well.

Also be sure to join the Prim&Prep community! Not only will you have a chance to WIN your choice of a quality safety razor or beard oil but we will provide you with all kinds of helpful and enlightening male grooming tips and advice directly to your inbox so you don’t have to waste your time fiddling on the web to find the right information to look and feel your best. There is nothing to lose and so much to gain. SIMPLY SUBSCRIBE BELOW!

Enter for a chance to win a free Merkur Long Handle(180) Safety razor or Bottle of Beard oil! It's your choice! The winner will be announced on the first of each month.

Make sure to confirm your email to enter to win! 

One more step! Please check your email to confirm:)

Share This

Like or share this!