5 Best Beard Dyes of 2019 Reviewed (Ultimate Buyer’s Guide)

If you are not quite ready to surrender to the march of time, there are a number of high-quality products out there to keep the gray out of your muzzle.

In this article, we’re going to take a look at some of the best beard dye on the market today to help you find the right one for you and your beard.

Use the table of contents below to jump to the sections most important to you.

Table of Contents

Best Beard Dyes Feature Image

Things to Consider When Buying Beard Dye

Before we get to our beard dye reviews, in this first section we’ll highlight (no pun intended) the features and some things that you should consider whilst reading our reviews and selecting your product.

Remember them, and they will help you to find the right product to suit your needs, as each design feature will be more or less important depending on what you’re looking for in the dye that will be best for you.

1. See The Light


Choosing a beard dye color option

The first consideration, and probably the most important, is choosing the color of the hair dye for your beard.

Not only is it the most important, but it can also be extremely hard, though a lot of guys won’t believe that.

Some guys will think, “Hey, I know the color of my hair, right? I mean, it is my hair…”

That’s true, we’re sure you know your hair color.

But there can be subtle variations both between the color of your head and beard hair and also in terms of the coloring that beard dye will provide.

The most common mistake we see with first-time beard dyers is that they dye their beard too dark.

What we recommend therefore is that, at least for the first time you try a dye job, go a shade or two lighter than what you think you need. 

Of course, if you’re bald, you can do whatever you want!

2. In for the Long Haul?


Time beard dye will last

The next thing you need to decide is the length of time that your beard dye will be in place on your beard.

Again this is a big consideration for first-time dyers, many of whom assume that beard dye is a long-term solution.

Whilst that is true and beard dye can have a long lifespan after application, it also doesn’t need to be the case.

There are several different options out there on the market for you to choose from.

Permanent, as the name implies, is going to stick around for a while.

You can expect anything from several weeks to even months of gray coverage.

Semi-Permanent is going to give coverage for up to a few weeks.

The final level is more of a temporary cover-up style of beard dye. They can often have life spans of around 12 hours and are easily washed out.

Selecting the lifespan of the product is an important consideration, especially when dying for the first time.

Yes, a permanent dye offers a long-term and cost-effective solution.

But when you are learning to use dye for the first time, and picking out the color that best suits you, it can be better to try out products with a shorter lifespan in case you make any mistakes.

3. The Breaking Bad of Beard Dye


Level of difficulty of beard dye application

No, we are not suggesting you add crystal meth to your beard dye.

That is a not some secret life hack to aid better dye lifespan or something like that.

No, here we are talking about the application of the beard dye.

Specifically, we are saying do you want to need a chemistry lab that would put Walter White to shame just to get that dye onto your beard?

As we shall see on the product list below, some dyes are easier to apply than others.

Just bear this in mind when selecting your dye, and look for one with an easier application method if you want fast and simple use.

Powder-based hair dyes, for example, can boast a lot of positive features.

But ease of application is not going to be one of them, with you having to mix up the powders yourself into a paste prior to application. 

A beard dye already mixed will, generally speaking, be quicker and easier to apply, especially if the formula is quite thick.

4. What’s in the Box?


Quality of ingredients (chemical vs natural)

No matter what the ingredients found in your box of beard dye, we promise they will not be as scary as Gwyneth Paltrow’s severed head.

That being said, there can be a whole host of chemical nasties in there that can (heavy emphasis on can, not will) be harmful, especially if you have sensitive skin.

Now, there is nothing wrong with chemicals in principle.

Heck, water is a chemical, and you wouldn’t expect plain water to be harmful to your beard or your skin.

Unless your beard is actually made of compacted sugar, in which case we just have to ask why?

Not all chemicals are made equally of course and some are harsher than others.

If you have sensitive skin, keep an eye out for hypoallergenic hair dyes.

There are also dyes out there with all-natural ingredients if that is important to you too.  

Don’t be scared of chemicals, they are all around us. But also don’t feel like you have to use a dye loaded up with a laundry list of them if, for whatever reason, you don’t want to.

There really are dyes out there to suit everyone.

5. It Rubs the Lotion on its Skin


Ammonia in beard dye

One final shout out to anyone with sensitive skin is to avoid products with ammonia.

Now, this chemical does get a bad rap as being quite harsh and, in truth, if you have sensitive skin, it really is one to avoid.

It does, however, play a very important role in dying hair.

Basically, ammonia encourages the hair follicles to essentially open their surfaces.

This allows the dye to penetrate into the hair itself, not just adhering to the hair surface.

That, in turn, makes for a deeper, longer lasting dye.

If you have sensitive skin, avoid ammonia, it’s not worth the skin irritation.

If you have relatively robust skin though, don’t be afraid of ammonia as it plays an important role in getting the deepest beard coloring you can.  


The 5 Best Beard Dyes of 2019 Reviewed

1. Just For Men Beard Dye Brush-In Color Gel

Just For Men Beard Dye Brush-In Color Gel

Next up we have a great product from a company that needs very little introduction, Just For Men.

They are one of the most famous male hair dye producers out there, so just what is this product from this very well trusted brand bringing to the table?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for an easy to use dye option from a company they can trust.

Color Options

Just For Men Beard & Mustache Dye Color Options

Key Features

To us, the big stand out feature with Just for Men beard dye is the same as it has always been – ease of application.

We always expect that products from them are easy to apply, and we’re happy to say that this is the case here.

Firstly, the dye comes premixed as a thick gel.

That eliminates drips (protecting your bathroom worktops) as well as making it nice and easy to apply to your beard.

Throw in the very well designed application brush that comes in the pack and you have one of the easiest to apply products that we’ve ever come across.

There is no point in applying a product with ease if it’s not going to do the job however.

Happily, that is not the case with this product.

It boasts a highly effective, semi-permanent level dye that does a great job covering grays and, as an added bonus, is ammonia free.

It is also available across 11 different colors, meaning there should be a dye to suit your own particular hair color.

Throw in the fact that you can get multiple applications from a single box and you also have a product with very good value for money.

As a brush based product, it may not be ideal for very large beards, as application time is going to stretch as the mass of beard increases. But for shorter to medium length beards, this is a simple, easy to use but highly effective way to hide those gray hairs.

See the collective opinion of over 1,000 reviews here on Amazon.


2. The Henna Guys Hair & Beard Dye

The Henna Guys Hair & Beard Dye

We’ll continue our list with this all-natural product from The Henna Guys.

Whilst it has an ingredients list that is laudably free of artificial chemicals, how does it perform as a beard dye? 

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for a highly natural beard dye product.

Color Options

Henna Guys Beard Dye Color Options

Key Features

First of all, don’t worry about the fact that the packaging for this product features a woman.

Trust us, if she had a beard, she’d be using this product to dye it too!

That’s because whilst you will see an awful lot of women using this product on their hair, it is more than suitable for beards.

Not only that in fact, but it is a very impressive beard dye too.

Even though it is primarily designed for use on head hair you can have no worries about putting it on your beard.

That is because this product is extremely pure and all natural, being made of pure henna and a range of other natural herbs and powders.

There is no ammonia, no harsh chemicals, no additives or fragrances.

Don’t think for a second though that this product doesn’t have staying power.

Henna is of course famously used in the Far East for temporary skin tattoos.

That same level of coloring power is put to use dying your beard with this product.

The choice to use henna does in fact make a lot of sense.

It is all-natural but also extremely long-lasting.

When it comes to beard dye, what a great combination that is!

Check out the consensus of thousands of Amazon reviews here.


3. Godefroy Color Tint Kit

Godefroy Color Tint Kit

Next up we have this neat little product from Godefroy. Instead of an all-over application, this product is designed for a highly selective dye to target small patches of gray hair.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

If you want to tackle small patches of gray with high accuracy.

Color Options

  1. Light Brown
  2. Dark Brown
  3. Natural Black

Key Features

Whilst some beard dyes can be like a World War 2 carpet-bombing with wide coverage but little accuracy, this product is the exact opposite.

To that end, if you are looking to cover larger areas of gray hair, then move on – it will simply take way too long to get the job done with this product.

If however, you have a beard that is graying in patches only, instead of all over, then pull up a chair, as this product could be the one for you.

Instead of being designed to cover large areas, you instead get a dye kit built for small areas.

That means a handy little brush is supplied along with an oxidant developer, a handy mixing bowl and 20 pre-measured dye capsules.

This is actually a really good design that is simple to use.

You open one capsule of powder into the bowl.

Mix in a squirt of developer and mix with the brush.

Apply it to your gray hairs and leave it to soak into the gray patches.

Done, nice and simple and very clean.

It is also good to note the product is both ammonia free and long lasting.

With up to 20 applications in one box, this product also represents very good value for money.

Like we said up top, if you value your time don’t get this if you have a lot of grey.

But if they are coming through in patches and you don’t want to dye the whole thing, this could be an effective solution.

See what hundreds are saying per the reviews here on Amazon.


4. Clairol Natural Instincts for Men

Clairol Natural Instincts for Men

The third product to make our list is this, a semi-permanent dye from Clairol.

This world famous brand is perhaps better known for creating top quality products for women but as they show here they are also big players in the male market.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for a high quality, all natural semi-permanent dye option.

Color Options

Clairol Beard dye color options

Key Features

This is our semi-permanent offering though it is certainly toward the upper end of lifespans for this style of dye.

That means that you are looking at around four to six weeks of effective coverage with this beard dye.

To us, that time span is sitting very nicely in a zone that is long enough you are not re-touching the dye too soon, but nor are you making the commitment of being in long-term, permanent dye territory.

This is also another dye that is not specifically for beards.

You will in fact see on the packaging (and read in a lot of reviews elsewhere) that this is a high-quality head hair dye.

We know for a fact though that many men also use it as a beard dye and we have of course tested it ourselves – and we are all very happy with the results.

It is the ingredients of the product that make it suitable for beard dying use.

It contains, as the name suggests, all natural products that make it sensitive enough for use on beard hair (and the skin underneath).

It is also fortified with various proteins, Aloe extracts, and Vitamin E.

All of these added extras combine to encourage the growth and maintenance of healthy beard hair.

See the customer reviews here on Amazon.


5. Blackbeard for Men Formula X

Blackbeard for Men Formula X

We’re throwing you a curveball with the last item to make our list!

Made by Blackbeard for Men, this final item is, strictly speaking, not even a beard hair dye at all.

Instead, it is an innovative product that provides a very short-term fix for gray beards.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for an effective but very short-term solution.

Color Options

Black Beards dye color options

Key Features

Here at PrimandPrep.com, we do have a soft spot for innovative products.

That may be one of the reasons that explain why we really like this product from Blackbeard for Men.

The other reason could be of course the simple fact it is cheap, easy to apply and highly effective.

We should point out, though really it should be obvious, that this is a temporary dye.

In fact, Blackbeard doesn’t even call it a dye, though in reality that is pretty much what it is.

When it is in place, you can expect the coverage to last about 12 hours or so.

So this is certainly no long-term solution.

But as a temporary cover-up before a big night out, important meeting, or job interview it could be just the thing you’re looking for.

We were very impressed with the ease of application too.

The solution itself is nice and thick, whilst the included application brush is very well designed.

It also achieves a nice, deep coloring of your hair and does so without any harsh chemicals or ammonias.

It is in fact hypoallergenic. Add that to the fact it is a temporary product and you have a beard dye that is perfect for people with sensitive skin.

There are four colors to choose from and each shares a very competitive price.

This may not be a product you look to every day.

But for short-term, effective gray coverage that won’t harm your bank balance, this could be a real winner.

Check what other customers think per the Amazon reviews here.


Benefits of Beard Dye

Benefits of Beard Dye

So you know what to look for in a beard dye.

You also now know what the five best beard dyes out there actually look like.

The next thing you may well ask – why bother?

1. A Younger You


Hey, we’ve all got to grow old, but who says we have to do it when Mother Natures tells us to?

The simple fact is that some men aren’t ready to go gray when the old gray hairs start spreading through our beards.

If that sounds like you, if the gray in your muzzle is making you look older than you feel, then beard dye is a simple but effective way to fight back.

2. Prepare for Interviews


It’s sad to say, but age discrimination remains a big problem in the US.

It’s sad it still exists, but the practical person will recognize this fact and work around it.

If you have an upcoming job interview, or if you are pushing for promotion in your current occupation, then beard dye can be a useful tool.

By covering up gray hair it can really help you to look younger, perhaps improving your chances in that interview.

3. Show Some Beard Love!


The last reason is kind of a personal one.

But if you love your beard, show it some love!

If you go to the effort of trimming your beard, oiling or balming it and combing it then there is no reason not to add dyeing it to that list too.


Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions
Why Can’t I Use My Wife’s Hair Dye?


Well for one thing she is really not going to thank you for revealing that she uses hair dye, especially to cover grays.
 
(Good job, dude).
 
Not only should you not use your wife’s hair dye because it’s going to piss her off, you should also avoid it because it’s not ideal for your beard hair.
 
To help us prove this point, just take a second to run your hands over your beard.

We’re guessing your beard hair feels a heck a lot coarser and tough than the hair on your wife’s head (or on your own if it’s not too short).
 
Head hair and beard hair are different beasts, as is the skin found underneath it.

Dye for the hair is generally harsher than that designed for the beard.

The reason for this is that head hair is generally longer and further removed from the scalp. 
 
Beard hair dye is therefore usually designed to be a little kinder to skin, whilst also being tough enough to penetrate tough beard hairs.

That’s a difficult juggling of priorities, resulting in beard hair dye being of a different formula to the typical head hair dye.
 
There are of course some exceptions to this rule.

There are in fact some exceptions that can be found on our very own product list above – aren’t we contrary, huh?
 
There are indeed some products marketed as being primarily for dyeing head hair.

But when you dig into the ingredients, it is clear they are also sensitive enough for use on beards.

Where we found products that did the job, we didn’t discriminate – no matter what was on the box.

Help! My beard is too dark now. Can I lighten it?


Well, someone didn’t listen to the section about choosing the right color, did they?

Don’t worry. It’s cool, we won’t hold it against you.
 
If you have dyed your beard and it has come out too dark, the first thing to do is to tackle it early.

Get yourself in the shower and give your beard a good wash with shampoo.

If you wash it quickly after dying, you’ll see the color lighten by a few shades.

Will the dye damage my beard hair?


It is very unlikely it will damage your hair.

That is especially true if you select a beard dye that is formulated for beards and their specific needs.

You are far more likely to make your skin itchy or irritated since your skin is so much more sensitive than your hair.


I made a mistake. How can I salvage my beard?


Well, there are a few options open to you.

As we talked about above, if the problem is that your beard has come out a few shades too dark then hop into a warm shower and give your beard a good scrub.
 
If the problems go deeper than that however, then you may need to take more drastic action.

One thing you could try is a good hair dye remover, such as this one from ColourB4.

Just be aware though that color removers are pretty harsh, and you will need to give your beard some serious TLC afterwards.
 
Of course, if you really dislike the outcome you always have the option to simply shave your beard off and start again.

After all, it will grow back again.

How often should I dye my beard?


The thousand-dollar question that sadly doesn’t really have an answer, or at least not one we can give you.

The truth is that you can dye your beard as many times as you like or as it requires.

If the gray is coming through, grab a fresh box and take care of it.
 
However, you must always be aware of course that each time you dye your beard you are opening it up to a bath in potentially damaging chemicals.

Choosing a longer lasting dye can cut back on exposure, as you simply need to dye it less often.

You can also look for dyes that are primarily made of natural materials and that may be gentler on your hair (and skin) in the long run.

Can I still use beard balms and oils?


Not only can you still use beard balms and beard oils – it’s recommended that you do so!

Look, we’ve been over this before and we’re sure you’ve heard it a thousand times already – but balms and oils are your beards best friends.

They help to keep it healthy and they help to keep it looking great.
 
None of that changes just because you’ve put some dye onto your beard.

So yes, do carry on with your regular beard maintenance regime after you have dyed your beard.

That means breaking out your beard comb, and it means carrying on applying your beard balms and oils.


How to Dye Your Beard

So you’ve got your safety razor in your hand and you’ve got stubble on your cheek.

Perfect.

The first thing you’ve go

Each beard dye product will have bespoke application instructions, so, as ever, we would strongly suggest reading any literature that accompanies your product.

That being said there are without a doubt some common themes across all products when it comes to the application of the dye.

There are also some useful hints and tips, and we’ll be passing a few of them on in your direction in this next section.

How to Dye Your Beard

  1. Perform a Sensitivity Check


    The first stage, before you break out any rubber gloves or brushes, is to perform a sensitivity check.

    We would strongly suggest you do this every time you apply a hair dye from a company for the first time.

    Simply apply a very small amount of the product to a patch of skin that’s out of the way. The inside of your forearm below your elbow is perfect for this.

    Leave the dye in place for 24 hours and check for any reactions or other skin sensitivity issues.

  2. Gather the Appropriate Tools


    Whilst you are doing this, you can gather up your tool kit.

    Depending on the type of dye you went for you may need a mixing bowl, rubber gloves and paper towels.

    If your product does not come with an applicator, an old (or new and cheap) toothbrush can be effective.

    No, do not use your actual current toothbrush to apply beard dye.

  3. Prep Your Beard

    If you have passed the sensitivity test and have gathered all your gear, the next stage is to prepare your canvass.

    There are some different schools of thought and some hefty debate about how clean your beard should be before you apply the dye.

    To us, it just makes sense that your beard should be as clean as possible before you proceed.

    A clean beard will be rid of debris and oils that can affect the adherence of the dye, so give it a good scrub in the shower before moving on to the dyeing stage.

  4. Apply Vaseline


    Here is our secret tip if you are wondering how to color your beard without staining your skin.

    Vaseline!

    Just smear some on the skin around your beard to avoid getting any product on your skin and staining it.

    Genius! 

    It’s also a good idea to throw on an old T-Shirt at this point, to avoid any drips of product staining your chest or shoulders.

  5. Prep the Beard Dye

    The next step is to prep the dye itself.

    The type of dye you’ve bought is going to have a big impact on this part.

    If, for example, you have bought a dye in powder form, you now need to mix it up with water to form a paste. 

    Some other dyes will come as two tubes, one being the base color the other being the color developer.

    The developer is there to thicken the dye and make it easier to apply to your whiskers.

    Again, mix the two products together in a bowl until ready to apply.

    Any product that requires mixing will always come with comprehensive instructions on how to achieve this so read up before you start in order get the right ratios.

  6. Apply the Beard Dye


    It’s now time to get busy dyeing!

    Grab your applicator brush (or your toothbrush) and dip it into the dye.

    Using the brush, work the product into your beard using an up and down movement.

    Once all the gray is covered, set a stopwatch for the time the product states it requires to do its work.

  7. Test the Color


    When you have waited the recommended time, you should test the color.

    Take a piece of paper towel and wipe away the dye from a small area of beard.

    Check out the color of the hair left behind – if you’re happy, move to step 8.

    If not, reapply a little more dye and give it a little more time.

    Repeat this step until you’re happy with the color.

  8. Wash it Off


    Hop in the shower and rinse off the dye.

    Keep rinsing until the water runs clear.
     
    Congratulations – you should now have a gray free beard!

0 thoughts on “5 Best Beard Dyes of 2019 Reviewed (Ultimate Buyer’s Guide)”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.