Looking for the best shaving cream for sensitive skin?
A shaving cream that won’t irritate your skin, make you break out, or cause razor bumps, but still give you a top quality shave?
If so, you have come to the right place!
Our experts have diligently tested and retested all of the specially designed shaving creams for sensitive skin to find out which ones really make the cut.
Below you will find the definitive list of the top performing shaving creams for sensitive skin, including some all-natural options.
We have provided you with important information about why and who should be using sensitive skin shaving creams and what you should look for when selecting the right shaving cream for you.
If you don’t have particularly sensitive skin and truly want the best, be sure to check out our reviews of the top shaving creams for men.
Use the table of contents below to go to the sections most important to you
Table of Contents
Top 4 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin Reviewed
#1 Taylor of Old Bond Street: Jermyn Street Collection Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
One of our perennial favorites in nearly every shaving category, Taylor of Old Bond Street’s “Jermyn Street” line is marketed primarily for men with sensitive skin.
This one features a very light fragrance compared to most of TOBS other products, which is specially designed not to irritate sensitive skin (despite containing a small amount of citrus essential oils).
If you’re looking for a traditional, old-school shave cream that won’t irritate your sensitive skin, this is one of our top choices and one that fully justifies its cost.
#2 Face Skin Care: Ultimate Comfort Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
Unscented and free from parabens and other harsh chemicals, this product works equally as well for men or women and virtually guarantees a close, painless shave.
Although it does contain a small amount of alcohol, the aloe, coconut oil, shea butter and glycerin more than makes up for it.
Still, the real star of the show is lidocaine, which works to somewhat numb the face to prevent pain and irritation.
#3 Zirh Sensitive Skin Shaving Cream
Another one of our favorites, Zirh Sensitive Skin Shave Cream contains numerous ingredients that help soothe, moisturize, nourish and protect the skin—including aloe vera juice, oat extract, glycerin and jojoba oil.
Not only does it help to prevent irritation, but it also has an incredibly calming effect on the skin and comes highly recommended.
#4 Kiss My Face Fragrance-Free Moisture Shave
Probably the most readily available product on our list, men and women have been raving about Kiss My Face’s products so much that we had to give it a try.
This one contains a comprehensive list of ingredients that work wonders for sensitive skin, including peppermint (antiseptic properties), lady’s mantle (astringent), soapwort (helps cleanse and fight against acne), vitamins A & E, aloe, coconut oil and more.
We found this to be one of the slickest and most lubricating products we’ve tried and can recommend it based on quality and cost.
Top 2 Best Natural Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin
#1 Pacific Shaving Company All Natural Shaving Cream
Although the products above are all great for sensitive skin, most of them still couldn’t be termed “all natural”.
So, if you’re looking for something that will help eliminate your skin issues and contains only natural ingredients, Pacific Shaving Company’s All Natural Shaving Cream is right up your alley.
With a very pleasing, mild fragrance and a ton of great natural and certified organic ingredients to help moisturize and protect your face, this may be one of the best shaving creams we’ve yet to come across—natural or otherwise.
Not only that, but one tiny tube of it lasts an incredibly long time, more than justifying its cost.
#2 Dr. Bronner’s Naked Unscented Shaving Gel
While not technically a shaving cream, we still had to include Dr. Bronner’s Unscented Shave Gel, as it is all natural and works wonders for those with sensitive skin.
In fact, all of the company’s shave products are quite good, but we chose the unscented version as it is likely to be one of the least harsh shaving products you’ve ever used.
While it may not lather up like you’re used to, it still provides plenty of lubrication and gets the job done.
The Many Benefits of a Top Quality Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
Choosing the right shaving cream can go a long way towards determining the difference between a “good shave” and a bad one, as it helps to lubricate the face better and prevent razor burn, skin irritation and other common problems associated with shaving.
While this is definitely true for all men, for no one is it truer than for those of us who have overly sensitive skin.
Whereas men with hardier skin may be able to use cheap aerosol shaving creams with no adverse effects, men with sensitive skin are probably fully aware of the limitations of these products and how much they can exacerbate their skin issues.
Similarly, there is also a growing section of men who are looking to ditch the chemicals and who would prefer instead to find a more natural shaving cream solution.
Either way, if you happen to be in one of these two groups, you’re in luck, as we’re here to help by providing you with more info on the best shaving cream for sensitive skin and also the best natural shaving cream (which are often one in the same, as we’ll explain below).
Who Benefits From Using Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin?
Men with overly dry skin
If you routinely find your face to be extremely dry, red, itchy or flaky after shaving, you need to find a better shaving cream that will help moisturize and nourish your skin.
Men with eczema, psoriasis or other skin conditions
Similarly, harsh chemical shaving creams can make these problems much worse, so you’re much better off with a more natural product.
Men with acne problems
Similar to the group above, if you suffer from acne, switching to a more natural shaving cream may help.
Men that experience severe razor burn, razor bumps or ingrown hairs
These problems could be related to your razor, shaving technique or personal hygiene (not adequately washing your face before shaving), but they may also be connected to your choice of shaving cream.
Why Use Sensitive Skin Shaving Cream?
Most likely you’re already aware of whether or not you have overly sensitive skin (especially if you fall into one of the categories listed above), but there is also a reasonably large group of men who continue to use regular shaving creams when they could, in fact, gain some significant benefits by switching to a sensitive skin shaving cream.
In simple terms, if you find that you continually suffer from pain, irritation, razor burn or other issues after shaving, one of the first things you should do is check out the ingredients in your current shaving cream as there’s a good chance that is the culprit behind many of your problems.
Of course, if you still use a cheap cartridge or disposable razor, this could also be part of the issue, which is why we recommend all men switch over to a safety razor (or a straight razor if you’re willing to go all out).
We won’t go into great detail about the differences in various types of razors (you can read about that in our article on safety vs. straight razors), but basically all you need to know is that those multiple blade razors tend to remove too much skin and natural oils with each stroke, which leads to increased pain and irritation.
Still, no matter what type of razor you’re using, the ingredients in your shaving cream can play a significant role in how your face feels post-shave.
If you’re using an aerosol shaving foam or any other shaving cream that contains chemical ingredients, it is highly likely that these will be much harsher on your face.
So, our first bit of advice to men with sensitive skin is to avoid any shaving creams that contain unpronounceable chemical ingredients and instead choose the best natural shaving cream.
In fact, that is why we’ve decided to group the best shaving cream for sensitive skin and the best natural shaving cream together, as most products we’ve included can fit in both categories. While Gillette and many other major companies produce a wide variety of canned shaving creams marketed for men with sensitive skin, we would recommend that you avoid these, as virtually all of them contain chemicals that can wreak havoc on sensitive skin (no matter what the companies claim).
The biggest problem with these canned shaving creams is that they require the use of propellants to eject the cream from the can and these propellants are known to dry the skin out severely.
So, to counter these effects, the manufacturer then adds many other chemicals that can further increase irritation for those with sensitive skin.
Therefore, instead of using an aerosol shaving cream, we would recommend you choose one of the products from our list of the best shaving cream for sensitive skin (alternatively, you may also want to check out our post on the best shaving gels, as they may also help).
What to Look for When Selecting a Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
- No harsh chemicals
- Fragrance-free (in many cases, the perfumes used may be the culprit behind your skin issues; this mainly goes for synthetic fragrances, but also for harsher essential oils like lemon or orange)
- Doesn’t come in an aerosol can
- Contains shea butter, natural oils or glycerin (all provide better lubrication)
- Contains aloe vera (this will help soothe & protect the face)
Related Resources You Need to Check Out
Ben Rose is the founder and senior editor at Prim&Prep, the definitive guide to male grooming. He is a wet shaving expert and body grooming aficionado. His work has been featured on many other prominent publications including Good Men Project, Addicted to Success, Steven Aitchison, and Sharpologist.