7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of 2019 (With All-Natural Options!)

Shaving and sensitive skin are not exactly two things that go hand in hand.

We mean just think about it, if you have sensitive skin, then the last thing you want to do is drag a razor sharp piece of metal across it.

The alternative is to just let your beard grow wild and free.

But with sensitive skin, that option can lead to the dreaded beard itch.

In this article, we are going to show you that there is another way.

That by investing in a high-quality shaving cream designed to soothe sensitive skin you can follow your own grooming regime without having to worry about irritated skin.

All of these shaving creams have earned a 5-star rating for their own reasons and thus have made it on this exclusive list.

QUICK OVERVIEW: Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin

IMAGEPRODUCT
7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of [year] (With All-Natural Options!) 1
Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
  • Very Mild Scent
  • Contains Aloe!
VIEW ON AMAZON →
7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of [year] (With All-Natural Options!) 2
Proraso Shaving Cream, Sensitive Skin
  • Very Rich & Creamy Lather
  • Contains Oatmeal and Green Tea to Soothe Skin
VIEW ON AMAZON →
7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of [year] (With All-Natural Options!) 3
The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream, Unscented
  • Simple, Effective Product
  • Easy to Apply with Brush or Hands
VIEW ON AMAZON →
7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of [year] (With All-Natural Options!) 4
Neutrogena Men’s Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin
  • Great for People With Acne
  • Compatible With Huge Range of Razor Types
VIEW ON AMAZON →

Use the table of contents below to jump to the sections most important to you.

Table of Contents

best shaving cream for sensitive skin

Things to Consider When Buying Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin

Before we get to our shaving cream reviews, in this first section we’ll highlight the features that you should bear in mind whilst actually reading the reviews.

Remember them, and they will help you to find the right cream to suit your needs and the needs of your skin.

Remember that each feature will be more or less important depending on what you’re looking for that will make the right shaving cream for you.

1. Natural Ingredients


Quality of ingredients

Hey, you know what you should shave with?

Gasoline.

Yeah, just get a handful and throw it on your face.

Don’t bother with a razor either, a piece of broken glass will do.

No we’re kidding, don’t pour Gasoline on your face.

You probably didn’t even need to tell that right, because you just know that there are some things that are not suitable for rubbing on your soft little face.

Same applies with shaving creams, especially if you have sensitive skin, and stand a risk of getting razor bumps, this will make things worse.

To that end, we have packed out our list with shave creams that take advantage of a shopping list of natural oils such as coconut oil, extracts, and essences.

We have everything here from good old Aloe (more on that in a minute) to left field stuff like oatmeal.

Yeah, that’s right, oatmeal.

It’s a great way to start the day and it’s also good for your skin.

Who knew?

Bottom line:

We’ve done our best to ensure the products on this list are formulated with as many natural products as possible.

That, we feel, is going to go a long to way to helping sensitive skin.

2. Contains Aloe


Aloe Vera

Whilst there are a number of quality natural ingredients to look out for, one stands head and shoulders above any other.

We are of course talking about Aloe, a natural extract that is well known for it’s various and many positives when it comes to caring for sensitive skin.

Of particular interest to those with sensitive skin is the fact that Aloe is so good at reducing skin irritation and inflammation.

We joked in our intro above that when you have sensitive skin the last thing you want to do is scrape a razor sharp blade over it.

But if you’re shaving, that is exactly what you are doing!

Choosing a shaving cream set up for sensitive skin is a big step to help overcome that by minimizing irritation.

Picking one with Aloe is an extra step to consider taking, as it will help to soothe any irritation that does occur from the shaving.

3. No Harsh Chemicals


Level of difficulty of beard dye application

There are a wide range of chemicals and preservatives that, if at all possible, should be avoided.

There is a whole range of reasons to avoid them, but one of the big ones is that they can really do a number on sensitive skin by drying it out, irritating it, and failing to provide enough protection to it during your shave.

All of the products on this list are free of harsh chemicals.

Not only that, but they are formulated to use as many natural ingredients as possible.

This is not just in terms of them being packed full of natural oils and extracts such as we talked about above, including Aloe.

It’s also about them keeping out harsh chemicals as much as possible.

That will go a long way to protecting your skin from damage.

4. Shaving Lubrication


Shaving Cream Lubrication

We are going to talk a heck of a lot about moisturizing and soothing skin in this article.

We’ve started doing it already, devoting the slot above to Aloe and its incredible powers of skin soothing.

And that’s important, especially with sensitive skin.

You need a shave cream that can soothe your skin and help prevent irritation.

But do you know what else you need to do with your shave cream?

Yeah that’s right – you need to shave with it!

So that’s why you need to look for a high degree of shave lubrication.

All we really mean here is that the shave cream should help the razor blade to glide smoothly and easily over your face.

That will help cut down on irritation, razor burn, and little nicks and cuts.

And that, in turn, will help protect your sensitive skin.

Awesome!

5. Price


Consider Price

Throwing money at a problem is one way to solve an issue – just ask any aging millionaire with a hot blond on their arm.

(Course they enjoy your personality, guys.)

We could give the same advice when it comes to your shaving cream, but we know that’s kind of unfair too.

Look, there’s a reason why you can pick up a can of mass-produced shaving cream at the Wal-Mart for a buck or two.

Skincare is not necessarily an area that many guys want to invest the big bucks in – or in some cases, they just can’t spend a huge wedge on a cream.

That’s cool, it’s fine and it’s something we recognize.

That’s why you will find products on our list below that range in price from close to thirty dollars all the way down to 10 bucks or so.

That’s still a lot more than a can of crap from a discount store.

But at the end of the day, we’re not here to lie to you, and you do need to spend a little extra to get a bit of quality.

When it comes to shaving with sensitive skin, we’re not asking you to short the economy to afford super premium creams.

But on the other hand, every extra dollar you can invest in your shaving cream will bring a return in terms of quality of product and ingredients.


Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin (2019)

1. Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

We’ll kick off our list with this entry, a true classic style of sensitive shave lotion all the way from merry old England.

Ready for a close shave, guv’nor?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for a high quality, traditional style shaving cream that is also tailored to protecting sensitive skin.

Key Features

Taylors of Bond Street have been around since 1854, spending all that time creating high-end shave products that are infused with quality natural essences and extracts.

They have made their way onto our other lists of best shave creams, but are representing here with a cream specially formulated for all of us with sensitive skin.

The first thing they have done for this specialist cream is to load it up with Aloe.

As we talked about above in our features section, Aloe really is a super important ingredient to look for in a quality shave cream that will help soothe and manage sensitive skin.

(You did read the features section, right?)

There are two other features we really liked about this cream.

The first is that the scent is very, very mild.

The top note of the fragrance is Cedarwood by the way, if you are interested in stuff like that.

But we were pleased to see the scent is so mild, as a high level of perfume can be one of the factors that sets off sensitive skin.

The other pro is that this is a water-activated cream.

That means it lathers up well, which in turn helps lubricate the razor blade across your face, cutting down on irritation and razor burn.

One negative is that you do need a shave brush to apply this cream.

To us though this is only a negative if you don’t have a brush already and have to buy one.

But to be able to use a quality cream like this one, that seems a small investment to us.

Check out the hundreds of Amazon reviews here.


2. Proraso Shaving Cream, Sensitive Skin

Proraso Shaving Cream, Sensitive Skin

We’ll continue our tour of Europe’s best sensitive shave creams with this next entry from Proraso.

This Italian brand has been in action since 1948, and if there is any European country that truly understands style and grooming, it has to be the Italians.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

If you are looking for a quality shaving cream without breaking the bank, this could be the one for you.

Key Features

There are two stand out features here that make this a top quality shave cream for those with sensitive skin.

Firstly it is designed to create a super-rich and creamy lather.

This will be extremely useful if you want to put on a comedy bra made of shaving cream.

It also has a practical application though.

A thick and luxurious lather is another way to ensure that your razor is nice and lubricated as it is doing its stuff cutting your stubble.

We should point out too that the thicker a shaving cream lather is, the worst it will work with modern, multi-blade style disposable razors.

So you will be best off using as a straight razor or a safety razor if you want to go ahead and shave with this cream.

The other thing we liked about this cream is that it is fortified with a number of natural extracts, chief amongst them being green tea and, a little strangely, oatmeal.

Whilst there is no Aloe to be found here, instead, these two ingredients work to help soothe sensitive skin.

So that’s why we like this shave cream.

It is nice and thick so as to avoid as much irritation as possible and it also contains natural ingredients to soothe whatever irritation does come up during shaving.

It also has a very nice fruity smell, which is a little different from the usual scents you get with most shaving creams.

Oh, and it’s pretty cheap too.

All in all then a “molto buona” shaving cream for sensitive skin.

Check out the collective opinion of customer reviews here on Amazon.


3. The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream, Unscented

The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream, Unscented

The next shaving cream on our list is from one of the premium male grooming brands, The Art of Shaving.

Does this shaving cream stand up to its reputation and higher price tag?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for a premium but unscented shaving cream.

Key Features

Hey, we get it, everyone likes to smell nice.

You know, that’s why perfume smells likes roses not Durian fruit or old cheese.

But if you are suffering from sensitive skin then you may need to pass up on the artificial fragrances, at least in terms of your shaving cream.

There is growing evidence out there that fragrances may not be the best thing for some people with sensitive skin.

The trouble is, it can be hard to find shave creams that come with scent.

Luckily we were able to find this product here.

We were lucky on two counts.

First up it has no scent at all.

In an unscented shaving cream, having no scent is… well its kind of important.

Secondly, we are lucky because it is The Art of Shaving that is bringing this product to you.

They are a company with a stellar rep for producing high quality, premium grade shaving creams.

This cream here, the only unscented version they carry, is very much living up to that high benchmark.

It is in many ways a very, very simple cream too.

So you are missing the scent (duh), but you are also not going to see an ingredients list packed out with ingredients – no essential oils or Aloe to be found here.

Instead, this is a simple but effective glycerin-based shaving cream.

The glycerin is important, at it really helps to make a slippery surface that lubricates the razor as it travels across your face.

Not only that but it means that it foams up nicely, making this a product that can be applied with or without a shaving brush.

Don’t think that just because it does not have the same amount of ingredients as similar creams it is going to be cheaper though.

What ingredients are here are all top quality, and The Art of Shaving is a premium brand.

Expect to drop a few more bucks on this one than on any other product on this list.

But also rest assured that this is a product that is very much worth that extra investment, especially if you are looking for an unscented product.

Check out the Amazon reviews here.


4. Neutrogena Men’s Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Neutrogena Men’s Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

The next product to make our list is this product from Neutrogena, one of the world’s most famous skin care product producers.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man who suffers from acne or similar skin conditions related to shaving.

Key Features

We picked this product for our list because whilst it is designed for sensitive skin, it also has a specific aim too.

If you suffer from razor burn or acne related to shaving, then this could be a product that you should take a look at.

First of all, Neutrogena has designed this product to be non-comedogenic.

Now that’s a mighty big word alright, but basically, it just means this shaving cream has been formulated to wash away cleanly without clogging pores.

That is a huge step in the right direction if you need to eliminate or control acne caused by shaving.

Neutrogena has gone the extra step and produced oil-free formula in this cream too.

That will also help to protect your pores from clogging.

This is also a sensitive shave cream.

To that end, there is no fragrance at all, but also no dyes – too often artificial ingredients can anger up the skin, Hulk Style.

Except it swells up red instead of green.

So it’s good they are not present here.

This is also a shave cream of course, so how does it shave?

Pretty well is the answer there.

It comes loaded up with what Neutrogena call their Pro-Soothe Technology.

This is supposed to help the razorblade glide easily over the skin, preventing snags, cuts and irritation.

It does work very well, and you can get a nice close shave, but it’s a just a fancy name for what is probably just glycerin.

Yeah, we’re cynics.

Bear in mind this is a gel product too.

That means it doesn’t lather up much, something that some people don’t like much.

If that doesn’t bother you and you find you skin is very irritated after shaving then this could be the right cream for you.

Check what others are saying per the Amazon reviews here.


5. Gillette Satin Care Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel

Gillette Satin Care Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel

Yeah, we’re coming way out of left field with this next entry!

But bear with us, read the review and see where we are coming from here.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for a cheap but effective shaving cream for all over body use.

Key Features

Yes, this is women’s shaving cream.

Gasp!

But it actually makes sense that it’s made its way onto the list here, if you think about it.

Women, it turns out, shave a heck of a lot more than most men.

Seriously, think about it!

Most guys are shaving a little patch on the bottom of their faces.

Women are shaving their pits, their legs and all over the place.

It makes sense then that some of the best shaving creams out there are designed for, and marketed to, women.

So take a deep breath and have a beer or something.

Buying a product branded for women won’t turn you into a soy boy.

Now, this product is not suited for everyday use on your face.

Men’s face hair is just so much coarser and thicker than women’s leg hair, this cream does not really provide the level of shave lubrication for the heavy-duty blades found on our face razors.

This product is though perfect for any men who shave below the neckline.

We’re talking if you trim up your chest, your twig and berries (and be careful down there), your back, your legs or a combination.

If you have sensitive skin on your face, you probably have it elsewhere too – and who wants shave rash on their nuts?

No one, that’s who.

So if you shave elsewhere, don’t waste your 20-dollar face shave cream on your butt crack.

Pick up this stuff for a few bucks instead.

It is fragrance-free, dye free and has been approved for use on sensitive skin by dermatologists – and they know what they are talking about.

Take a look at the Amazon reviews here.


6. Cremo Coconut Mango Moisturizing Shave Cream

Cremo Coconut Mango Moisturizing Shave Cream

The next cream we’ll take a look at is this effort from Cremo, which is very much from the budget end of the market.

Despite that though it has a lot going for it if you are looking for a quality shave cream.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for a highly natural and cruelty-free budget cream that is as gentle to the skin as it is to your bank account.

Key Features

First off all, yes, this is the Mango scented version of Cremo’s Orginal Shaving Cream.

This version is also marketed as a women’s shave cream, though we have no idea why.

It is exactly the same in every way as the original cream, it even has the exact same (and very low) price tag.

The only difference is this version has a really nice mango smell, which, quite frankly, we really liked!

Don’t judge us, Mango is nice.

If you prefer the unscented version, click the link above to get to that one.

Either way you are getting a high-quality shaving cream here, packed with a number of great features to help you shave effectively with sensitive skin.

First of all this cream is packed – packed we tell you – with natural oils and extracts.

Everyone is present here from Macadamia Seed Oil (packed with Omega 9 oil to moisturize the skin), Lemon extract (packed with vitamin C for healthy skin) and even Papaya extract (to make you strong like Popeye).

Our old friend Aloe is also here to help soothe your skin during and after shaving.

The cream itself is designed to provide a highly slick shave to lubricate the blade.

It is also quite easy to apply, and you can lather the cream up in your hand.

You do need quite a bit to get a good lather going however.

As a final bonus, the product is cruelty-free and is also excellent value for money with a two pack currently costing a shade over 10 bucks.

See the consensus of customer reviews here on Amazon.


7. Nivea Shave For Men Sensitive Shaving Gel

Nivea Shave For Men Sensitive Shaving Gel

We’ll finish off our list with this product, a shaving cream made by one of the titans of skincare, Nivea.

There are a lot of nice features here but there is also a reasonably big price tag too.

So is Nivea the right brand for you?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men looking for a brand name but still a high-quality product that is particularly well suited for shaving with Acne.

Key Features

As we mentioned above, this is a great shaving cream to consider if Acne is a symptom of your sensitive skin.

First off, this shave cream is formulated with both Chamomile and Aloe extracts, which both work together to provide deep soothing action during and after the shave.

That can really help to tackle Acne and keep it under control.

It’s a great sign too that this product is formulated without alcohol.

As we’re sure you’re aware by now, Alcohol is basically Agent Orange for sensitive skin, so it’s great to see it is not present here.

In fact, this cream is free of a whole range of stuff – from Dyes and Parabens to CFC’s – all of which can be bad news for sensitive skin.

So it’s good to see this is a nice, mild cream that omits all that crap.

Nivea has also thrown in their Skin Guard Technology formulation that is designed to lubricate the skin and protect your face during shaving.

Again, and call us cynics, but it’s probably just the glycerin that is right there on the ingredients list.

But you know what, it works, so if it makes Nivea happy to call it a silly name, who cares.

It will protect your mug from razor burn and other nasty effects, and that is the most important thing.

All in all, this is a remarkably mild shaving cream.

There is nothing here to cause concern, whilst the various natural extracts (including Aloe) will really help to soothe and protect sensitive skin.

It is not cheap, but you do know you are getting a quality cream from a well-regarded skincare manufacturer here.

See the many Amazon reviews here.


That’s our rundown of the seven best shaving creams for sensitive skin on the market right now.

When you have chosen your cream, the next thing you’re going to want to do is to start shaving with it, right?

Wrong.

Before you dive in, just take a couple of minutes to read our FAQ on sensitive skin and the shaving creams designed for it.

Go on, it’ll be fun.


Frequently Asked Questions

Why do I have sensitive skin anyway?


Who knows.

Sorry, we don’t mean to be flippant here, but the truth is that nobody knows why you, specifically, have sensitive skin.

That’s because there are a whole host of reasons behind it.
You may have a medical condition like eczema or rosacea or dermatitis.

You may be exposing your skin to too much environmental damage – whether from the sun, from cold temperatures or dry winter winds.

It could be that you are using the wrong shaving cream right now, one that is chock full of artificial ingredients and harsh chemicals.

It could be none of those things, or it could be a combination of several.

It doesn’t matter why you have sensitive skin, it only matters what you do about it. 

Choosing a shaving lotion form this list, one that will soothe and protect your skin, is a big step forward.

Is Shave Soap better than Shave Cream for sensitive skin?


Ah, the old battle between soaps and creams.

Soap is better because it’s the traditional product. Don’t mess with tradition, stupid!

No cream is better, it’s the modern version, why are you stuck in the past with your VHS tapes and Star Wars: Phantom Menace figurines, you loser.

Yawn.

As far as we are concerned, there are big pros and cons to both shave soap and also to shave cream, bottom line though they both deliver a great shave.

When it comes to shaving with sensitive skin though then we are going to lean heavily toward recommending shave creams.

We mean, you can surely guess this from the fact that there are no shaving soaps in product guide above.

To us, we just find that shaving creams are better able to suspend the natural oils, extracts, and Aloe.

This means the cream itself is rich with all that good stuff, which in turn means it is right there all over your skin right where you need it from the very first moment of application.

Shave soap is great too, and once you have practiced and can lather it up properly, it can deliver just a good a shave as a cream.

But it is a skill, and there is less room for error when working with sensitive skin.

For its ease of use and the fact it can deliver intense hydration, lubrication, and skin soothing, we’d recommend a shave cream as the best for sensitive skin.

10 thoughts on “7 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin of 2019 (With All-Natural Options!)”

  1. I have sensitive skin and find that the only cream that really works for me is Jack Black’s supreme cream. Funny enough I actually buy it in a high end clothing store.

  2. I find your article helpful, thanks! My brother has a sensitive skin, I will share this article with him. I admire your shaving cream recommendations they are thoroughly described.

    1. Hey,

      Funny you mention that! I actually finally completed a complete new round of research and testing and added Jack Black shaving cream to the list! Check out the new and improved buyer’s guide

  3. Hi Ben !!!!
    I’ve bought Nivea sensitive foam, few days ago, nice packaging but after i used it gave a burning sensation!!!!!
    Omg I’ve used other foams but I’ve never experienced a sensation like that. I don’t have a sensitive skin, I bought it by coincidence.
    Could you tell what’s wrong with it?
    Did they put something very chemical on it ???

    1. Hi Artur,

      That is very unusual. I haven’t heard of such a reaction before. I would definitely advise you discontinue using it immediately and go another direction. There are some other great options on the list that I am confident will not result in such a reaction.

  4. Hi Ben,
    I have really sensitive skin (along with dry skin and KP). While I’ve tried several different brands, I always seem to break out after shaving. Yes, even with the Nivea and Neutrogena I still break out!! Do you have any advice on what to do from here? Thanks!

    1. The shaving cream may not be the problem. A couple of other reasons may be:
      1. It may be your shaving routine. Are you washing your face before you shave?
      2. Maybe the razor you are using is the issue. Which razor are you using and how often are you replacing the blades?
      3. What is your aftercare routine? Are you using an aftershave and/or moisturizing lotion? You should be using an aftershave with some antiseptic properties to kill any bacteria as well an oil-free moisturizing lotion. There are aftershave balms that can do both.

      Hope this helps!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top