All You Need to Know About the Best Shaving Oils
When it comes to getting the closest, smoothest shave possible, many men swear by using a pre shave oil. For those of you that have never tried a shaving oil before, the purpose of these products is to help soften up your facial hair before you shave and also to lubricate your skin to allow the razor (best safety razor) to gently glide across your face. This not only can result in a closer shave, but it can also help to reduce the amount of irritation your skin feels post-shave, as long as you choose one of the best shaving oils or else otherwise you may just end up a greasy mess.
The one bad thing about many pre shave oils is that they do have a tendency to clog up the razor, so you’ll likely need to rinse your blade off much more than normal. However, that is really only a minor inconvenience compared to the quality of the shave you’ll get with a high-quality pre shave oil. That being said, there are literally hundreds, if not thousands of shaving oils on the market, and they’re definitely not all created equal.
So, to make things a bit easier for you, we’ve tested many of the top brands and products on the market to help you find the best pre shave oils.
Best Pre Shave Oils
Best General Purpose Products:
If you don’t have extra sensitive skin or any special needs, you’ll probably be ok with using most any pre shave oil you come across. However, considering the quality and the price, you definitely can’t go wrong with the fantastic shaving oil from American Crew. Featuring eucalyptus, clove, peppermint and a number of other natural essential oils, this antibacterial oil can help prevent irritation and also ingrown hair and razor bumps. Plus, with a price less of around $15 for a 1.7 ounce bottle, it’s one of the cheaper high quality oils you’ll find.
We really couldn’t decide between the American Crew product and Taylor of Old Bond Street’s amazing Sandalwood Pre-Shave Oil. While some find the scent on this product to be a bit overpowering, we find it to be just the perfect amount, as it soon fades away after shaving. As far as performance goes, you won’t find a much better product, which isn’t surprising since Taylor of Old Bond Street is one of the top names in the barber business. It may be a bit more expensive at around $25 for a one ounce bottle, but it’s definitely well worth the price, especially considering the fact that the bottle should last for months as you only need a few drops at a time. Taylor of Old Bond Street’s Sandalwood shaving cream also made the cut for the best shaving creams and best shaving soaps as well. Pairing both their pre shave oil and one of their shaving creams or soaps is a great combo.
- Get it here on Amazon
- Don’t just take our word for it, check out all the other glowing user reviews here.
#3 Art of Shaving Pre Shave Oils
Art of Shaving is one of the biggest names in men’s shaving and grooming products, producing a huge range of popular products that many men swear by. They even made the top of our list for the best aftershave balms. We were however, when it comes to the company’s pre shave oils, you’d be hard pressed to find a consensus opinion. Some men love these oils, while many others find they don’t do much. While we probably wouldn’t rank the Art of Shaving oils that highly based on our own experiences, there are enough positive reviews out there that we definitely had to at least mention them. As of last check, their products were available in either an unscented version or several different choices of scents, including Sandalwood, Lemon and Lavender. While we weren’t wild about the performance of the Art of Shaving oils, we have to say that the Sandalwood fragrance was incredibly nice and almost worth it for that alone.
Best All-Natural Pre Shave Oil:
Badger Navigator Class Man Care Pre Shave Oil. 100% natural and all-organic, there is no doubt that this incredible product from Badger is at the top of the class. In fact, if it wasn’t for the fact that we decided to make a separate category for all-natural products, there’s every bit a chance we would have ranked this product number one overall—it’s simply that good. However, like some of the other pre shave oils, the smell of this product may take some getting used to or simply may not be for everyone. Still, if you’re looking for something that’s organic and free from harsh chemicals, while still getting the job done, look no further than Badger. Badger has a great line of male grooming products. They also made our list for the best beard oils and best chapstick for men.
Best for Sensitive Skin:
Anthony Logistics. For people with sensitive skin, you’ll probably want to stay away from most normal pre shave oils, as the essential oils many contain may be too harsh for your face. For this reason, you may be better off going with a pre shave oil like the one from Anthony Logistics, which doesn’t contain essential oils. This natural product is fragrance free and 100% hypoallergenic, making it perfect for even the most sensitive skin. Not only that, but it contains vitamin E to help condition the skin and calendula to help soothe the skin after shaving. Overall, this is hands down one of the best pre shave oils for sensitive skin on the market today. Anthony Logisitics also produces one of the best shaving gels as well. Also be sure to check out are article on the best shaving cream for sensitive skin as well.
Honorable Mention: Dermalogica Close Shave
Another one of the best pre shave oils for those with sensitive skin is Dermalogica Close Shave, which is also hypoallergenic. In truth though, we’ve yet to try this product out, but after hearing so many good things, we figured we had to include it on the list.
Best Cheap Pre Shave Oil/Best Beginner’s Oil:
Shave Secret. Those of you that have seen this product on sale in your local Wal-Mart might be laughing that we’ve included in on the list. In truth, it’s probably the only product on our list that you can easily find at any local store, and at less than $10 a bottle, it’s definitely the cheapest product on our list—but the price is the reason it’s on here. In fact, we decided to create a separate category for cheap products just so we could mention it. Shave Secret is a blend of natural oils and essential oils, with just a hint of soothing menthol. Since using pre shave oil isn’t for all men, if you’d like to give it a try without spending too much cash, Shave Secret is definitely a good option.
Best Non-Traditional Pre Shave Products:
Proraso PreShave Cream. Proraso has been a staple for Italian barbers for decades, but only recently has the rest of the world begun to catch on to the secret. Featuring menthol and eucalyptus, this product not only gives a smoother shave, but also helps to cool and soothe the skin once you’re finished. Not only that, the strong fragrance is sure to clear your sinuses along the way. This is another product that’s not technically an oil, but as it’s still used in the same way, we thought we’d include it on our list of the best pre shave oils. When using Proraso, rub a tiny amount of the cream onto your wet skin immediately before applying shaving cream or soap. You’ll not only get a fantastic cooling and tingling sensation in your face, but also a much better shave. They also made our list of the best aftershaves for men as well.
Über Close Shave Gel. Another product that uses all natural and organic ingredients, Über Close is also suitable for vegans, which is partly why we’ve decided it deserves a mention. However, the real reason we’ve included it is that it’s really more like a combination of pre shave oil and shaving cream in one. While all of the other products are designed to be used in conjunction with shaving cream or soap, Über Close is a transparent gel that you rub directly into your facial hair, let sit for a few seconds and then start shaving like normal. You’ll be pleasantly surprised at how smooth and painless of a shave this product can provide, and it may even convince you to ditch the shaving creams for good.
Wm. Neumann & Co. 1911. This is another product that is easily good enough to make it into the overall list of the best shaving oils, but we’ve decided to include it in the non-traditional category for the fact that it is much thinner than any of the other oils we tested. If you’re one of the men who find shaving oils to clog up your razor too frequently, we highly recommend giving this product a try. Similarly, many straight razor shavers dislike oils because they’re too hard to wash off the blade in between strokes, but the thinness of this product helps eliminate that issue as well. Featuring a very masculine scent, with numerous woody and citrus fragrances, this pre shave oil is sure to not disappoint. While it may seem a little silly, another thing we loved about this product is the lid. While many products have lids that full screw off, making it easy to pour out too much, the lid on this bottle only unscrews part of the way, making it much easier to control how much you’re pouring out to ensure there’s no waste.
In truth, there are so many good pre shave products out there, that trying to narrow it down to a list of the best pre shave oils was quite difficult and we had to leave many deserving products out. So, if you’re willing to do some experimentation and try out different products on your own, you may easily come across something that works much better for you than anything we’ve already mentioned. Moreover, every man’s face is different and not everyone wants the same thing in their pre shave products, meaning it’s really a matter of personal choice. Still, if you’re looking for a quality product, you could do a lot worse than the products we’ve covered here—all of which should help give you a closer shave with less irritation. Alternatively, you could always try to make your own pre shave oil. Also be sure to check out our article on the best shaving creams as well.