9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of 2019 (For a Superior Shave)

Shaving creams and shaving razors go together like peas and carrots.

Now, as we’ve already taken a look at the best safety razors out there on the market, it just made sense for us to take a look at shaving creams too.

Shaving cream isn’t just there to help with shaving of course.

High-quality creams will help to promote healthy skin that you will see and feel.

Most importantly they help you to shave your facial hair without ending up a weeping, bloody mess.

So in this article, we’ll help you find the best shaving cream to suit you, your skin and your beard.

We’ll look at the features to bear in mind when making your selection, and then take a deep dive review into nine (nine!) of the very best shaving creams on the market right now.

QUICK OVERVIEW: Best Shaving Creams for Men

IMAGEPRODUCT
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 1
Truefitt & Hill Shaving Cream – Trafalgar Scent
  • Glycerin-based
  • Comfortable shaving
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 2
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream
  • Easy lathering
  • Moisturizes your face
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 3
Proraso Shaving Cream
  • 95% Natural
  • Cruelty-free
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 4
Jack Black Beard Lube Conditioning Shave Cream
  • Softens Hair
  • Makes shaving easy
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 5
Cremo Original Shave Cream
  • Leaves skin smooth and soft
  • Reduces cuts, nicks, scrapes & irritation
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 6
Geo. F Trumper Coconut Oil Soft Shaving Cream
  • Gives an excellent, creamy lather 
  • Prevent dryness to the skin
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 7
The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream
  • Generates a rich and foamy lather
  • Protects the skin from irritation & razor burn
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 8
Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Shaving Cream
  • Soothes Skin
  • Cool for your carry-on
VIEW ON AMAZON →
9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 9
eShave Shave Cream
  • Opens pores, softens hair & protects skin
  • Eliminates shaving irritation
VIEW ON AMAZON →

If you have particularly sensitive skin, I would highly recommend you check out our buyer’s guide on the best shaving creams for sensitive skin.

All of these shaving creams have earned a 5-star rating for their own reasons and thus have made it on this exclusive list.

Use the table of contents below to jump to the sections most important to you.

Table of Contents

Best Shaving Cream for Men

Things to Consider When Buying Shaving Cream

Before we get to our shaving cream reviews though, in this first section we’ll highlight some of the key features that you should bear in mind whilst reading the reviews themselves.

Remember them, and they will help you to find the best men’s shaving cream to suit your needs, as each feature will be more or less important depending on what you’re looking for in the cream to lather up your precious little face. 

1. Lubrication


Shaving Cream Lubrication

The first feature to look out for is lubricating your shave.

Yeah we know, call us crazy but we think that the best design feature of a shaving cream should be the ability to help you to have a smooth shave.

Look for a shaving cream that softens the hair, prepping it for that shave.

Frankly, all the grooming products on this list will do that, so don’t worry too much.

We’re just highlighting this fact though because you will still get some dopes out there who say shaving cream is a waste of money.

Don’t listen to them – or rather let their dried out, patchy skin covered in razor burns and cuts speak for them.

We mean come on, if you’re going to ask what does shaving cream do, it’s number one function is to provide a smooth shave.

2. Hydration


Moisturizing Shaving Cream

A good shaving cream should also be able to hydrate the skin, though if it can’t, it is certainly not a deal breaker either.

For example, we’ll look at a brand called Geo F. Trumper below (great name, huh?).

It’s not a great moisturizer, because it is a traditional style of shaving cream.

That means it gives a great, smooth shave – but you will be better off applying a little extra moisturizer afterward.

Not the end of the world!

If you want a cream that does it all for you, look for natural oils and things like aloe or Shea butter in the ingredients list.

3. Type of Application


Brush vs brushless shaving cream

How do you want to get your shaving cream from the jar onto your face?

Do you prefer a close shave or otherwise?

If you like to just use your hands, don’t get a cream that is best applied with a brush.

We have provided more information in the FAQs below describing the differences between brush vs. brushless shaving creams.

You’ll see examples of both kinds of shaving creams below.

We even sniffed out a few that can be applied with bare hands or with a brush, for all you indecisive types.

4. Scent


Fragrance or Unscented?

We know that scent is very personal to every guy.

Because of that, we’ve tried to describe as well as possible what each product smells like.

Until they invent scratch and sniff Internet though, you got to use your imagination a little.

We do get asked about unscented shaving cream from time to time, but truth be told it’s darn hard to find a good one.

Instead, we’ve highlighted the products below that have a particularly weak scent, the closest to unscented we could find.

5. Your Hair


Consider Price

The last feature to bear in mind, but no means the least important, is price.

In an ideal world, you could just throw money at the problem and shave with, we don’t know, scrambled Condor eggs, if that gave the best results.

In an ideal world, Emma Stone is just changing into a bikini to come join us in our private pool as soon as this article is finished, so none of us are living in an ideal world, ok?

Where were we?

Price, right.

Again we’ve highlighted the price of each option and pointed out which ones represent the best value for your money.

Along with your razor though, this is one area of your grooming arsenal that we would suggest you drop a few extra bucks on if you can.

The difference between a chemical/dye packed can of crap from the supermarket and a quality non-aerosol shaving cream such as we will look at below really is huge.

It has a big, big impact on the health and appearance of your skin and to us, and hopefully to you too, that’s worth a few bucks.


Best Shaving Creams for Men in 2019

1. Truefitt & Hill Shaving Cream – Trafalgar Scent

Truefitt & Hill Shaving Cream – Trafalgar Scent

We’ll kick off the list with this very traditional style product that comes all the way from London.

This shaving cream has been around for over 100 years, but why has it stuck around for so long?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for a shaving cream that is fit for royalty…

Key Features

Just take a look at the lid of the product to see the first stand out feature of this shaving cream from Truefitt & Hill.

Yep that’s right, it’s a royal crest, because this cream is made by appointment to H.R.H the Duke of Edinburgh.

He may not be good at driving cars anymore, but he does have great looking skin for a man of this age!

Part of that may well be down to this shaving cream, which beyond the royal warrant is also packing a number of very impressive features.

For one, it is loaded up with good old glycerin.

As we discussed before, that is going to make for a shaving cream that is providing an excellent level of skin hydration.

This product also provides a super smooth surface.

Again that is going to help your razor to glide easily over your face, cutting back on potential rashes and skin irritation.

This is not an unscented shaving cream.

Now, the scent is described as “Trafalgar.”

Does that mean this shaving cream smells of gunpowder and amputated arms?

Thankfully, no it is more of a sandalwood overtone, with a spicy background scent.

It’s a very masculine aroma, lets just say that.

There are many more scents available as well if that Trafalgar doesn’t suit you.

One downside is that this product seems to have a pretty short shelf life.

Once it’s opened, it will start to dry out quite quickly.

You can pick up a little bottle of glycerin though and just moisten it every now and then to stop that issue.

See the Amazon reviews here.


2. Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street shaving cream

What is it with the Brits and top quality shaving cream, huh?

The next product is yet another from across the pond, and again it is a high-quality product.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Men who really appreciate a traditional style of shaving cream.

Key Features

Taylor of Old Bond Street has been around making quality shave products way back since 1854.

It’s fair to assume that they may have picked up a thing or two in that time about shaving cream, right?

Well, they have. Well done guys, have a crumpet.

First off, this is a shaving cream in the absolute definition of that word.

It is thick and luxurious. As well as lending this product a truly high-end feel, that thick cream nature also makes it easy to lather.

In fact, whilst the product comes with a handy little bowl to mix it, you don’t even need to use it.

It’s so thick, you can dip the tip of your shaving brush into the product and lather it up right on your face.

In use, this is a pretty simple style of cream.

It isn’t packed with the natural oils and extracts that you will find in other creams.

It is in fact quite a synthetic blend, although it is still far milder than what you will find streaming out of a can of commercial shave cream from Walmart.

But in use, it is going to soften the hairs and it is going to moisturize the skin.

That is what you want in a decent shaving cream and this product will do that easily and quickly and also for a very reasonable, budget-level price.

One thing to note is that the thickness we talked about does make it harder to wash off when you are done.

Check out the collective opinion of thousands of reviews here on Amazon.


3. Proraso Shaving Cream

Proraso Shaving Cream

Next up is another traditional product, this time from Proraso. It is packed with two key ingredients – Menthol and Eucalyptus Oil.

Just make sure, given the product design, that you don’t mix it up with your toothpaste and try to brush your teeth with it.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

If you are looking for a shave cream that makes an incredibly rich lather.

Key Features

Two of the big stand out features in this traditional style of shaving cream is the inclusion of Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol Oil.

First of all, those two natural oils lend themselves heavily to the scent of this product, which is dominated by the Menthol.

But they aren’t just there for the smell.

The Menthol is designed to cool and calm the skin, helping to avoid razor burn and also helping keep your skin look happy and moisturized after shaving.

The Eucalyptus Oil is also there to aid the skin, being included for its ability to tone and purify it.

Bottom Line:

This product is designed to be extremely kind to skin and leave it looking great.

This shaving cream also has a very interesting manufacturing process.

It is made in Italy, where Proraso only makes it in small batches.

These batches are allowed to sit for 3 days in a “hot soap” style process.

In the end, this ends up making a shaving cream that generates an incredibly rich and deep lather.

That makes it ideal to use with straight and safety razors.

Beware though that it will likely clog a cartridge or a disposable style razor, especially those ones that have about 17 blades in the design.

Also be aware this is not quite a fully natural shaving cream, containing 5% synthetic ingredients. 

See the consensus of thousands of customer reviews here on Amazon.


4. Jack Black Beard Lube Conditioning Shave Cream

Jack Black Beard Lube Conditioning Shave Cream

First of all, no it’s not that Jack Black.

But whilst you may not be getting a shave cream that is personally designed for the School of Rock star himself, you are still getting a very cool three-in-one style beard cream here.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for something that is totally different from any other shave cream out there.

Key Features

Yeah that’s right, this product is actually kind of keeping with its namesake, by kind of coming from left field a little bit.

On the one hand, it is similar to many other shave creams by employing an ingredients list chock full of all natural products – this is, in fact, the first largely organic shaving cream to make our list.

Amongst those ingredients are well-known ones like Menthol and Peppermint Oils, both well known for their ability to cool and soothe the skin. There are also some other favorites of skincare like Eucalyptus oil.

Also in there is a product that is a little different, Macadamia Nut oil.

That’s not something we see very often in shave creams, despite the fact that it is very good for your skin.

So yeah there is a lot going on here for your skin.

That’s because this is actually a three in one style of product.

Fooled you! Didn’t see that coming, huh?

Oh, we said that up top did we?

Well, fool us once…

This shave cream is, well it’s a shave cream, and that’s why it’s here.

But it’s also a pre-shave oil and a skin conditioner all rolled into one.

Some have found it’s better at being a skin conditioner than being a shave cream.

Like we said above, it is packed with high-quality ingredients that will really, really help your skin to survive the shaving process intact and even glowing.

On the lubrication side, this shaving cream doesn’t perform quite as well as the others.

It doesn’t lather, at all. That means you can’t use a brush, you have to use your hands.

That, in turn, makes it harder to apply properly.

It is also completely transparent – as in totally see through.

This can be seen as an advantage when shaving a beard line but also can making shaving more of a guessing game as the what portion you have shaved and which portion you have not.

See what hundreds of people have said per the reviews here on Amazon.


5. Cremo Original Shave Cream

9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of [year] (For a Superior Shave) 10

Cremo are the manufacturers of the next shave cream that we’ll take a look at today.

They state that their product is astonishingly smooth – is it just marketing talk or are they the real deal?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

If you want the ultimate smooth gliding shaving action with very little chance of nicks or cuts.

Key Features

Whilst the previous product we checked out was a great skin conditioner whilst being only providing average lubrication, the opposite is true of this product from Cremo.

This product has been designed from the ground up to provide a top quality shave.

It includes ingredients (Cremo don’t specify which) that are designed to interact with water.

When this happens, they create a super slick surface that any razor can easily glide over.

That really helps to cut down on accidental nicks and cuts with the razor.

Which is great!

But that’s not all.

By gliding so smoothly over the skin, this product really helps to dial down any skin irritation.

This is backed up by a number of skin-friendly ingredients such as Macadamia Seed Oil and Aloe, all designed to keep your skin healthy and happy.

This product also doesn’t lather too well.

On the one hand, for some people that will be a negative, as they like a good lather they can work into their hair and skin with a brush.

On the other hand that does mean this product can be used with just about any style of razor, from a straight razor to safety razor, and cartridge razor to disposable razor.

Lastly, as if it couldn’t get any better, this shaving cream really offers exceptional value for your money.

It’s pretty cheap to buy anyway, and it’s also super concentrated.

You only need a small almond sized portion in your hand to cover your face.

All in all, very impressive!

See the user reviews here on Amazon.


6. Geo. F Trumper Coconut Oil Soft Shaving Cream

Geo. F Trumper Coconut Oil Soft Shaving Cream

Another product coming from Jolly Old England, this is another very traditional style of shaving cream.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man who wants to shave like an old school gentleman.

Key Features

First of all, is there a more English name than Geo F. Trumper?

We love it, it sounds like a background character from Mary Poppins.

Don’t worry though, there is a huge range of impressive features that this cream is bringing to the market beyond its awesome name.

So what you got, Guv’nor?

First of all, just know that this is a very traditional style of shaving cream.

By that, we mean that it is not exactly chock full of ingredients designed to soothe or moisturize the skin.

Don’t get us wrong, it’s not harsh to the skin either.

There’s no alcohol to dry it out, for example.

But it’s not a high-grade skin moisturizer, just know that.

What it is though is a shaving cream for tough old school gents, designed to create a luxurious and deep lather.

To that end, it will work very well with straight razors, less so with disposables.

But if you want a traditional cream that will give you an awesome lather, this could be the one for you.

It’s also closer to an unscented shaving cream than you will find with many other products, having just a very mild coconut based aroma.

If you don’t like that, Geo F. Trumper also make the same product scented with Almond, Sandalwood, Lime and something called “Spanish Leather”. You can see all of the available scents here.

We have no idea what that last one smells like but we will admit, its kind of turning us on right now.

No, you’re the weirdo.

See the Amazon reviews here.


7. The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream

Art of Shaving, Shaving Cream

Next up is this product from the Art of Shaving.

It is very much from the premium end of the shaving cream market, so what is it bringing to justify the price tag?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man who is looking for a premium shaving cream that creates one of the richest, deepest lathers you will find.

Key Features

Glycerin.

It may not be the most glamorous of skin care ingredients but holy hell it is good for your skin.

This shaving cream, from The Art Of Shaving, is packed with the stuff.

That means it is great for your skin, really helping to lock in moisture for long-term protection against irritation and razor burns.

This product is also designed to create an incredibly deep lather.

It really does whip up into a shaving product that provides a huge level of smooth gliding action across your face.

Again, this is going to protect you from nicks, cuts and razor burn.

Awesome!

The scent of this product is dominated by Sandalwood, and whilst it is not overpowering it is quite long lasting.

If you like (or are indifferent) to the smell of Sandalwood, then this is a good feature.

In addition to good old glycerin, there are also a number of essential oils as well as coconut oil.

They are there to add an extra layer of moisturizing action from this product.

That, to a large extent, sums up why this is such a premium product.

The Art of Shaving has really put a lot of thought into formulating what is a high-quality shaving cream here.

It needs to be stated that this is a product with a premium price tag for a pretty small jar of product.

All we can do is lay out why it is worth paying it.

It’s up to you though to decide if you agree!

Check out the Amazon reviews here.


8. Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Shaving Cream

Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Shaving Cream

Caffeine doesn’t just serve a role as wake up juice to get you going before you head out the door in the morning.

It is also great for skincare, so we were very happy to find a shaving cream full of the stuff.

Specs

Who Is It Best For?

Any man looking for a natural shaving cream that is also boosted with a little something extra…

Key Features

Of course, the stand out feature here is the caffeine that is found in this product.

That’s because whilst this ingredient is getting more and more popular in various skincare products, it’s still not something we see in shaving cream too often.

Frankly, that’s a shame because it brings a whole heap of benefits to the table.

For one, it is a potent antioxidant.

That means that it will help to reduce puffy face as well as skin irritation during and after shaving.

That’s always useful in a shaving cream!

The caffeine has been boosted in the product by a range of other highly useful – and all natural – oil and extracts too.

We’re talking spearmint, sunflower oils, aloe and also shea butter.

They are all designed to really compliment that caffeine and provide a product that will deeply nourish and protect the skin.

It is also a good shaving cream, designed to help the razor blade (or blades) slide easily across the face.

It doesn’t lather too much either, so it is compatible with just about every type of razor on the market.

One complaint, and it is really the only one we have, is that the tube is so damn small.

3.4 Ounces is not a lot of product, even though you only need to use a small amount at any one time.

See the collective opinion of Amazon reviews here.


9. eShave Shave Cream

eShave Shaving Cream

We’ll finish up our list with this product from eShave.

This is very much from the more modern end of the shaving cream brands, so what it is packing to take on the old champions of the industry?

Specs

Who Is It Best For?


Men looking for a simple but highly effective shaving cream that is not packed with nasty chemicals or animal products.

Key Features

This product is all about giving a comfortable shave but with ethical considerations too.

To that end, it has been packed with a number of quality ingredients such as glycerin (vegetable sourced) and coconut oil.

This is, in fact, a vegan product, and no animals have been harmed in its manufacture.

Hey, if that’s important to you then it’s good to know.

If it’s not important, it doesn’t do you any harm so just go back to your bucket of wings.

We’re all God’s children, people.

Anyway, back to the shaving cream!

It is designed to generate an extremely rich lather, which serves two purposes.

One, it will open up your pores and soften your hairs, prepping your skin and stubble for the upcoming shave.

Second, it will allow that razor to glide smoothly over your skin.

Those two functions will both play a key role in helping you to avoid razor burn, nicks and cuts.

There is also coconut oil in the recipe here to help hydrate the skin.

Fragrance wise, the aroma is a white tea.

It’s not the most masculine smell, but it’s pretty mild and it won’t hang around for long.

It’s actually almost unscented really.

This truly is a high-quality shaving cream, packed with beneficial ingredients and lacking for any that will do you skin harm.

That’s pretty good all in all, though it is a shame that once again this quality cream comes in such a measly, 4 ounce jar.

It’s great quality alright, but it is not cheap either.

See what others have to say per the reviews here on Amazon.


That’s our list of the best men’s shaving cream on the market right now.

Have you already got a favorite?

Well hold your horses partner, we haven’t been through all the stuff you need to pick the best shaving cream for you!

In the next section, we’ll take a quick look at the different types of shaving cream out there.

Then we’ll finish up by answering some of the most frequently asked questions about this very useful product.


Types of Shaving Cream

Canned Shaving Cream


Traditional creams are, well, creams.

Yep, that’s the kind of scoop you come to Prim and Prep for, right?

The benefit of creams is that they are thick and packed with ingredients that soften the hair and soothe the skin – exactly what you want from a shaving cream.

They also allow you to apply them with a shaving brush, and we don’t care what anyone says – shaving brushes make for the best face prep routine for the smoothest shave.

Viscous Shaving Cream (No Brush)


The modern pretender to the throne of the traditional shaving cream.

We had a number of these products on our list, showing that they can provide a viable alternative to the traditional styles of shaving cream.

Yes, they also come packed with great ingredients to protect the skin.

Yes, they often have wide compatibility with a range of razors.

No, they can’t be applied with a brush – and that, to us, is why they will always be a  (very close) second place.


Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brush or No Brush application best?

Eh, we may be old dinosaurs (get off our lawn!) but to us nothing preps your face for a shave quite like a quality shaving brush.

The bristles help to lift and raise the hairs, making life easier for your razor.

When your razor is gliding smoothly there is less chance of rashes, nicks and cuts.

It also exfoliates your skin, removing the dead skin cells.

So that means your skin looks great.

On the other hand, no brush application is quicker.

If you need to shave in the morning before going to work, and you don’t have much time, we can see the benefit of not having to bust your shave brush out every time.

So really… we’ve got to stand by the fact that the brush helps give the best shave.

But we also understand the practicalities behind a shaving cream that can be quickly applied with just your fingers.

What is Shaving Cream?


We’ve come all this way and you’re going to ask that?

You know what, maybe it was your fault your parents got divorced.
We’re kidding!

Your parents got divorced cause your Dad screwed Mandy in accounts.

Or did that just happen to us?

Whatever.

Shaving cream is designed to be the lubrication between your skin and the razor blade.

That’s it.

All the other stuff like hydration or prepping the hair, they are nice bonuses.

Does the Type of Razor I Use Matter?

Yes, of course!

We highlighted this in our guide above, but if you prefer a modern disposable style of razor then you are best going for a shaving cream with limited lather.

On the other hand, if you like a traditional straight razor, try a traditional shaving cream that generates a huge amount of rich lather.

What is the best shaving cream for a safety razor?

Actually pretty much any of them, as this style of razor works with lots of lather but is also happy with a lather-less shave gel style cream.

18 thoughts on “9 Best Shaving Creams for Men of 2019 (For a Superior Shave)”

  1. I use the Pacific caffeinated shaving cream and it feels great on your skin and makes a very good lather. It runs 6-7 dollars in retail stores in the US.

  2. CommentHi, I recently acquired this cream and I can assure you better that Taylor, with very little cream on the brush makes an excellent foam and sensational perfume, the cream is called Apothecary87 and 1893 is from the UK, thank you

  3. Great review – add to your cream list to test out D.R. Harris and Nancy Boy. I find both of those to be exceptional creams and most often used in my pile. Nancy Boy especially satisfies in the hot and humid summer months and for sensitive skin it is wonderful. Harris has great conditioning and very nice scents. Just so many excellent options out there.

  4. Happy to see that Pacific Shaving Co. made your list! I’m about to try that soon on the recommendation of a work colleague! You can buy it in Target for around $5.50! Can’t beat that! Great article by the way! Thanks!

  5. I’ve been using Cremo for about a year. Outstanding lubrication and very economical. Re-wetting with fingertips brings the lube right back. Also doesn’t clog tightly spaced blades like many gels and foams. I prefer it in sandalwood, but the standard light citrus original is fine too. Target has handy travel size for a couple of bucks.

  6. I have a bald head and I’ve been using Cremo for quiet some time now and it’s my favourite to use. I usually purchase mine at Target as well. It leaves my skin soft and smooth and gives me a close yet comfortable shave with out the Nick’s and razor irritation. I would like to hear from the bald guys or Ben to see if they have any other recommendations for shaving creme or tips on getting that perfect shave ? Thanks

  7. I am a Cremo fan while using a Harry’s razor. The Cremo provides outstanding lubrication and guards against cuts. For the price, give it a shot and see what you think. Wetting your face with hot water for 30 seconds before use is the key.

  8. Jack Black
    Hey I think your ‘size’ description for the Jack Black shave cream is incorrect. You state it at 5 oz, but the Amazon link shows three sizes 3/6/16 oz…but none at 5oz so either its bad intel or a bad link

    Thanks for that the great shaving info.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top