Best shaving cream for men

Stop Torturing Yourself & Start Using the Best Shaving Cream For Men

Although any avid readers of our site should already be more than aware of this fact, it begs repeating that getting a close, quality shave requires using quality products. While this is obviously true when it comes to choosing a razor (check out our post on the top safety razors), even those of you who continue to insist on using disposables (best disposables) or cartridge razors (Mach 3 vs Fusion) will likely still see huge benefits from using a higher quality shaving cream. Still, the question then becomes trying to decide which is the best shaving cream for men.

 

There are so many thousands of different products on the market that actually finding the best shaving cream for men can be like searching for a needle in a haystack. This is especially true when you consider all of the cheap canned creams that have flooded the market. Although these products are fairly cheap and readily available, we really wouldn’t recommend them for anything but an emergency situation—when you desperately need a shave and there is nothing better at hand.

On the other hand, more traditional shaving creams typically don’t come in a can, but instead in a tub or a tube. Depending on the brand you end up choosing, you can probably expect to pay a bit more than you would a cheap canned cream. Nonetheless, most people don’t find it much of an issue to pay a few dollars more for the best shaving cream for men. Plus, although they may look a bit pricey at first glance, most of the products on our list of the best shaving cream for men will last much longer than those canned creams, as it only takes a small amount to build a good lather (especially if you use a shaving brush, which we highly recommend). Check out our other posts on what makes a quality shaving brush and how to build a lather with a brush.

So, instead of subjecting your face to the pain and irritation most of us tend to associate with shaving, do your face a favor—throw away that can and instead invest in the best shaving cream for men.

Traditional Shaving Cream vs Canned Shaving Cream

If you’ve never used a traditional non aerosol shaving cream, you really don’t know what you’re missing as there are huge differences between traditional and canned shaving creams—starting with the lubrication factor. In case you’re unaware, the entire purpose of using shaving cream is to help lubricate your face so that the razor slides gently over the skin. In simple terms, the better a shaving cream is at lubricating, the less irritation you’ll experience as a result of shaving.

The problem with most canned shaving creams is that they tend to use harsh silicones as a way to provide lubrication, whereas more traditional non aerosol shaving creams typically use glycerin (which is a far superior lubricant). Still, it’s not just in lubrication that canned creams fail to live up to traditional ones. While the majority of traditional creams use more natural ingredients, most canned products use a variety of different harsh chemicals that are meant to help keep the skin from drying out. The reason behind this is that the propellants used to eject the cream from the aerosol can are incredibly harsh and will quickly dry out the skin, thus making it necessary to add even more chemical ingredients to counter this effect.

So, all things being equal, your face would be much better off if it never came into contact with any shaving cream that comes out of a can. In fact, probably the only redeeming factor with these products is their easy availability, as most of the products we consider amongst the best shaving cream for men can only be purchased either online or in a specialty store. That being said, they are more than worth the effort it takes to find them, as they simply can’t be compared to all that cheap canned crap you’ve been using.

Best Shaving Cream for Men: Traditional vs Brushless

As we’ve already established, when we use the term best shaving cream for men we’re referring to traditional non aerosol shaving cream. However, there is still quite a bit of variety when it comes to these products, as some are still designed to be used with a shaving brush while others will still lather well without one. In truth, even with those products designed to be used with a shaving brush, it’s actually not necessary, but it will result in a better lather with less cream.

Criteria Used

To determine which shaving creams deserved to be placed on this coveted list of the best shaving creams for men, we based our assessment on the following 3 criteria:

Scent – The quality of the scent and the variety of scents available. This is probably the most subjective criteria as the desired scent is a personal preference. We integrated our own opinions along with the opinions of many people that we surveyed to come up with a score based on a general consensus.

Performance – This includes the latherability of the shaving cream such as how easy it is to create lather and the overall quality of the lather. This score also includes the quality of shave the cream delivers including how well it provides a close shave while minimizing irrtation.

Value – This criteria is based on the price, size of the container, and the longevity of one container based on normal usage.

Best Shaving Cream For Men: Our Two Cents

When we started out writing about the best shaving cream for men, we really didn’t know what we were getting into, as there are simply so many excellent options out there that it would be impossible to cover even half of them here. So, to shorten things up a bit, we’ve decided to only include traditional non aerosol shaving creams that are suitable for your average man on this particular list. However, if you happen to have overly sensitive skin, not all these products may be your best option, which is why we have written about the best all natural creams and the best shaving creams for sensitive skin separately.

 

 

 

#1 Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street shaving cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

If you’ve read any of our other best of lists, such as best pre-shave oils and best shaving soaps, then you’re probably already familiar with Taylor of Old Bond Street, which is just one of many in a lengthy line of outstanding British shaving companies. If we’re being honest, we’d probably have to say Taylor of Old Bond Street is hands down one of, if not the best shaving companies we’ve come across and their outstanding shaving creams are no exception. Available in more than 10 different scents, including Sandalwood (a personal favorite and the #1 best-selling shaving cream on Amazon), Coconut, Almond, Grapefruit, Avocado, Rose and fragrance free Natural, you’re sure to find a fragrance you love. Not only that, but in terms of performance, Taylor is far and away one of the best shaving creams for men around. Although it may be a bit more expensive than many others (at around $17 per 5.4 ounce container), we’ve yet to come across a single person who didn’t think it was well worth the added cost.

 

#2 Truefitt & Hill Shaving Cream

Truefitt & Hill shaving cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

 

Another one of the old-school English shaving companies (and another one of our personal favorites), Truefitt & Hill produces an excellent line of shaving creams and also made our list of the best aftershave balms. When it comes to fragrance, we find Truefitt & Hill to have one of the widest ranges, with smells like Trafalgar and Grafton having a more traditional shaving scent (that reminds many of their grandfathers) and fragrances like Ultimate Comfort, Sandalwood and 1805 having a more modern scent that’s popular amongst the younger crowd. The majority of these shaving creams are designed to be used with a brush, but the company’s No. 10 cream is a true brushless cream. All in all, there is no doubt that Truefitt & Hill produces some of the best shaving cream for men you’re likely to find, with the only negative being that their products are quite a bit more than most of the others on our list (around $40 for 6.7 ounces). Still, that’s probably to be expected from a company that is listed as the official shaving supplier for the British Royal Family.

 

 

 

#3 Geo F. Trumper Shave Cream

Geo F. Trumper Shave Cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

Another one of the traditional English companies to make several of our lists (we especially like their aftershave balm), we had to include Geo F Trumper Shaving Cream due to the fact that it offers easily as good or better lubrication than virtually any other product we’ve yet to come across. Like Taylor of Old Bond Street and Truefitt & Hill, Geo F Trumper produces a wide range of classic and modern scents, including some that most wouldn’t exactly consider manly like rose, limes or lavender. However, despite what you may think, these scents are incredibly pleasing and actually quite masculine. In fact, we’d probably choose the Rose fragrance as one of our favorites, as its only slightly floral and reminds us more of freshly washed laundry. All in all, Geo F Trumper produces some truly outstanding shaving creams for a fairly good price (around $30).

 

 

 

#4 eShave Shaving Cream

eShave Shaving Cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

If you’re looking for a traditional shaving cream that still builds up a rich, foamy lather like you’re used to, eShave Shaving Cream might just be your best bet. We consistently found it to have superior lathering potential compared to most others, no matter whether you use a brush or not. We also love the fact that it contains no parabens, animal ingredients, synthetic colors or sulfates, making it a great choice for the more health conscious guys out there. When it comes to eShave, you’ve again got quite a few fragrance choices, including our personal favorites Cucumber and White Tea. We also liked that eShave put a spin on the traditional sandalwood scent and found their Orange Sandalwood to be less overpowering and more pleasing than most other brands sandalwood products. The only thing to note is that unlike all of the others on our list, these products are not specifically designed for men, so you may want to stay away from the floral scent. That being said, none of the smells are overly feminine. It’s another one of those products that are a bit more expensive ($25 for 4-ounces), but considering its performance, we’d gladly pay double that amount—it’s that good.

 

 

 

#5 Art of Shaving

Art of Shaving

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

Of all the products on our list, Art of Shaving is probably the most controversial, as most men either love it or hate it. Still, considering how many positive reviews we came across, we figured we had to give it a shot—and we’re glad we did, as we were pleasantly surprised with its performance. In truth, it probably isn’t quite as good as the traditional English companies, but that doesn’t mean it won’t get the job done. Available in lavender, sandalwood, lemon and unscented versions, this cream works equally as well with or without a brush and is a favorite of many men. That being said, we’ve recently seen many reports about the quality being not nearly what it used to be (the company was purchased by Proctor & Gamble in 2009), as many men report it to be thinner and not as fragrant as it once was. Still, we can’t really comment on this since we didn’t get a chance to try it before, so you may want to read some more reviews if you’re considering picking this one up.

 

 

 

 

#6 Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Shaving Cream

Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Shaving Cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

The first shaving cream on our list to be made in the USA, Pacific Shaving Company’s unique Caffeinated Shaving Cream is like nothing else you’ve ever tried. We’ve all had those mornings when we’d rather not get up out of bed and it seems like no amount of coffee will get us ready for the day, which is exactly what this shaving cream is designed for, as it’s like a shot of espresso for your skin. Although many people are unaware, caffeine actually has numerous skin benefits, including reducing puffiness and swelling, which will help your face look and feel its best—no matter how late of a night you had. Still, the caffeine isn’t the only reason to love this shaving cream, as it also contains numerous organic and natural ingredients that help nourish and protect the skin, including aloe vera, spearmint, sunflower oil and shea butter. Plus, considering it typically sells for less than $10, we’d definitely recommend this for anyone looking for an excellent quality shaving cream for a decent price. All in all, we love everything about this product (although not all men are wild about the smell) and find it to be one of the most invigorating shaving products we’ve tested.

 

 

 

 

#7 Kiehl’s Close Shavers Squadron Ultimate Brushless Shaving Cream

Kiehl’s Close Shavers Squadron Ultimate Brushless Shaving Cream

Overall

Scent

Performance

Value

While most of the other products on are list work better with a shaving brush, Kiehl’s definitely has to be one of the best truly brushless shaving creams currently on the market and one of the only ones we’ve come across that you don’t need to add water to before lathering (it contains Sodium PCA, a natural ingredient that binds water to the skin). It won’t leave your face feeling dry or greasy like many others and offers an all around excellent shave. It seems to be especially popular amongst men who frequently suffer from razor burn, as most report the problem immediately went away as soon as they started using Kiehl’s. It’s also popular amongst men who are looking for a shaving cream with a milder scent. At around $20 for 8-ounces, it’s not only incredibly affordable but really works like a charm.

Hey! Don’t Leave Yet!

If you found this article helpful please be so kind as to share it on Facebook or other social media per the buttons below. We really would appreciate it as we have worked so hard on this post for you. I have a feeling some of your friends and family will find it helpful as well.

Also be sure to join the Prim&Prep community! Not only will you have a chance to WIN your choice of a quality safety razor or beard oil but we will provide you with all kinds of helpful and enlightening male grooming tips and advice directly to your inbox so you don’t have to waste your time fiddling on the web to find the right information to look and feel your best. There is nothing to lose and so much to gain. SIMPLY SUBSCRIBE BELOW!

 

Enter for a chance to win a free Merkur Long Handle(180) Safety razor or Bottle of Beard oil! It's your choice! The winner will be announced on the first of each month.

Make sure to confirm your email to enter to win! 

One more step! Please check your email to confirm:)

Share This

Like or share this!